Wednesday, February 11, 2015

Immigration: Whose Side is God on?

“If one attitude can be said to characterize America’s regard for immigration over the past two hundred years it is the belief that while immigration was unquestionably a wise and prescient thing in the case of one’s parents or grandparents, it really ought to stop now.  For two hundred years succeeding generations of Americans have persuaded themselves that the country faced imminent social dislocation, and eventual ruin, at the hands of the grasping foreign hordes pouring through her ports.”[1]

*******

The quote above, which comes from Bill Bryson’s book Made in America, highlights the mentality borne by natives of various countries and nationalities toward newcomers, foreigners, and all manner of strangers who arrive as immigrants to their land.  Whether it be Protestant immigrants fleeing to Switzerland in the 1600s to escape religious persecution, Calvinist Separatists fleeing England to begin life anew in the “New World,” or Catholic and Pentecostal immigrants fleeing harsh socio-economic environments south of the U.S. border, the native populations accepting these foreigners have always responded with xenophobia and hostility.  Meanwhile, those immigrating have often undertaken their journeys as though they were embarking on a religious “exodus” to a new land “flowing with milk and honey.”  In fact, for many undocumented immigrants the trek across America’s southern border is equitable to a Christian pilgrimage ordained by God, who offers aid to his devout followers attempting to sojourn from the south to a better life in the north. 

Are these immigrants right?  Does God help them to cross America’s southern border illegally?  Are they truly on a “pilgrimage” that God has ordained and set in motion?

According to Ben Daniel in his book Neighbor, we certainly cannot disregard the very real possibility that “God is walking alongside those who immigrate to the United States.”[2]  At the very least, we must recognize that such is the perception of those crossing the Rio Grande in search of better lives and opportunities in America.  As Daniel notes regarding the perspective of many immigrants:
“There is an overwhelming and growing sense among undocumented immigrants that their journeys are blessed by God…and the knowledge that they have arrived in the United States by the grace of God has helped to instill a particularly strong faith among many of America’s undocumented Christians.”[3]
These immigrants’ belief regarding their identity as sojourners and pilgrims who travel with God’s blessing can be further highlighted by some of the Scripture passages cited in common by numerous undocumented immigrants to offer them comfort and hope for their journey and the journeys of many others.  For example, Genesis 12:1-2: 
“Now the Lord said to Abram, ‘Go from your country and your kindred and your father’s house to the land that I will show you.  I will make you a great nation, and I will bless you, and make your name great, so that you will be a blessing.’” 
And also 1 Peter 2:11-12: 
“Beloved, I urge you as aliens and exiles to abstain from the desires of the flesh that wage war against the soul.  Conduct yourselves honorably among the Gentiles, so that, though they malign you as evildoers, they may see your honorable deeds and glorify God when he comes to judge.”
I think it hard to ignore how undocumented immigrants read themselves into these scripture passages.  Few native-born American Christians can readily assume an alien/exile mentality because, as citizens of one of the most prosperous empires in world history, the travails that accompany the experience of aliens and exiles are so far removed from our daily lives.  Yet, in the experience of immigrants who are making/have made their way to the U.S., the Christian walk (which is literally for them a walk) is intrinsic to their identity in Christ.  As states Daniel, “This distinctly immigrant spirituality is strongly dependent upon the Bible’s witness to a God with an affinity for those who live as sojourners in foreign lands.”[4]

I also find it particularly eye opening that in the 1 Peter passage, from the immigrant's perspective, we are the Gentiles.  We are those who malign the immigrant as an evildoer.  Moreover, as immigrants see it, God has directed their movement here, not only so that we might save some of them, but also so that they might save some of us.  It may strike us as absurd, but for many immigrants coming to America, their journey here is one of evangelism and revival that God has himself ordained.  M. Daniel Carroll R. asks in his book Christians at the Border:
“[C]ould what we are witnessing in this country be part of a divinely directed global phenomenon?  Is God bringing millions of Hispanics to the United States to revitalize the Christian churches here and to present to those who do not yet believe the opportunity to turn to Christ in their search for a new life?  Many Hispanics and pastors sincerely believe that God has led them here for a purpose:  to play an important role in the revival of the Christian faith in this country.”[5]

*******

As American Christians, we should not fail to recognize the immigrant roots of our faith; otherwise, we may only confirm Bryson’s observation regarding the double mentality held by all-too-many descendants of immigrants who view their parents’ and grandparents’ immigration as wise while simultaneously viewing all current immigration as a dangerous social ill.

We must further consider carefully what Ben Daniel has to say about the current situation befalling us today: 
“If God is walking with immigrants as they ford the Rio Grande, if God accompanies undocumented folks through the fiery heat of the desert, then perhaps American Christians need to walk with immigrants as well—not just to influence public policy, but to strengthen our faith and to deepen our spiritual connection to the Divine.”[6]





[1] Bill Bryson, Made in America, 176.
[2] Ben Daniel, Neighbor, 12.
[3] Ibid, 9.
[4] Ben Daniel, Neighbor, 9.
[5] M. Daniel Carroll R., Christians at the Border, 61.
[6] Ibid, 12.

No comments:

Post a Comment